Intent, warning, and why ignoring sound signals still causes collisions
Contents
Use the links below to jump to any section:
- Why Sound Signals Still Matter
- What Sound Signals Are Legally Meant to Do
- Manoeuvring Signals in Sight of One Another
- Sound Signals in Narrow Channels
- Sound Signals in Restricted Visibility
- The Difference Between Intention and Warning
- Sound Signals and COLREGs Authority
- Common Misuse and Dangerous Assumptions
- Radar, AIS, and Sound: How They Must Work Together
- When You Hear Signals but See Nothing
- When the Other Vessel Uses Sound Incorrectly
- Sound Signals During Pilotage and Manoeuvring
- Why Sound Signals Are Often Ignored on Modern Bridges
- Typical Accident Patterns Involving Sound Signals
- Practical Sound Signal Discipline for OOWs
1. Why Sound Signals Still Matter
Sound signals are often treated as obsolete on modern bridges.
This is a serious error.
Sound signals exist because there are times when:
- visibility is degraded
- electronic information is incomplete
- visual identification is delayed
- intent must be communicated immediately
Sound cuts through uncertainty.
When sound signals are ignored, bridges lose one of the last layers of collision defence.
2. What Sound Signals Are Legally Meant to Do
Sound signals serve two distinct purposes:
- Manoeuvring intention (what I am about to do)
- Warning / presence (where I am, especially when unseen)
They are not suggestions.
They are legal signals recognised under COLREGs.
Failure to use or respond appropriately can be used as evidence of poor seamanship.
3. Manoeuvring Signals in Sight of One Another
When vessels are in sight of one another in confined or close-quarters situations, sound signals communicate intended manoeuvres.
Key principles:
- sound signals announce your action — they do not ask permission
- signals must be made before the manoeuvre
- signals must be clear, correct, and timely
Common failures include:
- sounding after altering course
- sounding “out of habit” without manoeuvring
- assuming AIS intentions replace sound
Sound signals only work if actions follow immediately.
4. Sound Signals in Narrow Channels
In narrow channels, sound signals are particularly important because:
- manoeuvring space is limited
- bank effects reduce control
- overtaking situations develop quickly
Sound signals here act as early warnings, not last-second alerts.
If you wait until close quarters, the signal has already failed.
5. Sound Signals in Restricted Visibility
Restricted visibility is where sound signals regain primary importance.
In fog, heavy rain, snow, or sandstorms:
- visual confirmation may be impossible
- radar contacts may be ambiguous
- AIS data may lag or be incorrect
Sound signals serve to announce:
- your presence
- your type of vessel
- your operational status
They are not optional — they are expected behaviour.
6. The Difference Between Intention and Warning
One of the most misunderstood aspects of sound signals is this distinction:
- Intention signals say what I am about to do
- Warning signals say pay attention — danger exists
Confusing the two leads to dangerous assumptions.
Never assume that hearing a signal means agreement.
Sound does not equal consent.
7. Sound Signals and COLREGs Authority
Sound signals do not override COLREGs.
They support them.
If another vessel sounds an incorrect signal:
- you are not obligated to follow it
- you must still avoid collision
- Rule 2 responsibility remains
A wrong sound signal does not transfer liability — but ignoring it may.
8. Common Misuse and Dangerous Assumptions
Repeated sound-signal failures include:
- using sound to “assert right of way”
- sounding without manoeuvring
- not sounding because “radar shows CPA is fine”
- assuming small craft will respond correctly
- failing to sound due to bridge complacency
Sound signals are preventative tools, not formalities.
9. Radar, AIS, and Sound: How They Must Work Together
Sound signals must be integrated with:
- radar target analysis
- visual lookout
- AIS awareness
Sound fills the gap between detection and certainty.
If radar says something is there but you cannot identify it, sound signals help reduce ambiguity.
10. When You Hear Signals but See Nothing
This is a high-risk condition.
If you hear sound signals and cannot visually identify the source:
- assume restricted visibility rules apply
- reduce speed early
- avoid close-quarters situations
- increase CPA margins
- call the Master early
Do not wait for visual confirmation.
Sound signals exist precisely because visual confirmation may not arrive in time.
11. When the Other Vessel Uses Sound Incorrectly
If another vessel:
- sounds late
- sounds incorrectly
- sounds but does not manoeuvre
You must assume:
- confusion on the other bridge
- potential misinterpretation of the situation
- increased collision risk
Respond with space and time, not argument.
12. Sound Signals During Pilotage and Manoeuvring
During pilotage:
- sound signals remain valid
- the Master remains responsible
- pilots may expect sound discipline
Failure to sound correctly during manoeuvring is often highlighted in post-incident reviews.
Sound signals reinforce shared awareness — especially in busy port approaches.
13. Why Sound Signals Are Often Ignored on Modern Bridges
Common reasons include:
- over-reliance on electronics
- noise pollution in busy waters
- lack of recent fog experience
- cultural habits (“nobody uses them”)
This does not reduce their importance.
It increases the risk when they are needed.
14. Typical Accident Patterns Involving Sound Signals
Investigation patterns show:
- restricted visibility collisions at excessive speed
- sound signals not made or not interpreted
- bridges waiting for radar certainty
- delayed Master calls
Sound signals are often mentioned not because they were wrong — but because they were absent.
15. Practical Sound Signal Discipline for OOWs
A professional OOW treats sound signals as:
- early tools, not late warnings
- supplements to visual and radar information
- legally meaningful actions
Good practice includes:
- knowing signals instinctively
- sounding early when unsure
- reducing speed before sounding in fog
- documenting restricted visibility procedures
- calling the Master early
Sound signals do not replace judgement — they support it.
Tags
COLREGs sound signals · restricted visibility · manoeuvring signals · bridge watchkeeping · collision avoidance · maritime safety